Sunday, May 20, 2012
Gettysburg Reply (Jason Kong)
The Battle of Gettysburg was inevitably going to be a major battle because of the amount of soldiers fighting. Luckily, the union won and there was, finally, hope of winning, because a battle win of this caliber for the Confederates would have easily sealed the victory for the South. With the win, in Gettysburg, the would probably be a big morale drop for the North and a big morale boost for the South. Basically, the South winning the battle would be like a kind of final wake up call to the North that there was no hope of winning. Also, if the South came out on top, the armies of the North would have been heavily damaged, making a second battle meaningless. European countries like Britain and France would be "wow"ed by the battle win and choose to support the South in fighting because it would show that the South were really motivated and will stand there ground above all costs for there beliefs. The battle would change Lincoln's mind even. Lincoln would've seen that there was no way to win because the North was already losing a lot of big battles and winning in the West was just not going to cut it. In the end, Lincoln would have looked for a treaty to cease the fighting and let the Union fall.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Even if the Confederates won the battle, the outcome of the battle could have ended in ways in which the South was still at a disadvantage. For example, the Union might have done a great amount of damage to the Confederates before retreating. This would make it so that there is a loss of manpower to defend Gettysburg for the Confederates. The Union, after regrouping, could have attacked Gettysburg again, in the "Second Battle of Gettysberg" per say, and win anyways. There could have been a lot of factors that could determine the outcome of the battle, but the "Confederates winning" is too vague of a statement to find a real answer as to what would've happened.
ReplyDeleteI really agree with Eric. It depends, a victory could be like one of Antiatam, just more pushed to the confederate side. Or, it could be a total pubstomp, but right now to be honest i don't think that a victory would be a total gamechanger unless it was a really crushing defeat for the Union. In that case, everything you said would come to be, but other than that idk haha xD
ReplyDelete